# What a collections data programme actually costs.

A consumer-finance lender is choosing between a collections data programme and a voice bot. Both arrive as one budget line and promise the same thing. The question: for any call made last month, can you show the lawful basis, the hour, the person contacted, the number dialled, and evidence the call was conducted properly?

## What the evidence says

- **The conduct rules are now explicit.** A debt-collection code of conduct for member banks, issued 31 March 2026 and effective immediately, runs to three chapters and eleven articles. Drafted with the IFC across eleven rounds with 48 organisations and more than 370 comments, it covers every type of debt, and responsibility survives outsourcing.
- **The bucket structure is fixed, so your data must reproduce it.** Circular 11/2021 sets specific provisions at 0, 5, 20, 50 and 100% for groups 1 to 5, plus 0.75% general. Treatment logic that cannot reconcile to those buckets is untestable.
- **The history window is bounded.** Circular 03/2013 limits the bad-debt history supplied by the credit bureau to five years, so a contact strategy assuming longer memory argues with the law.
- **Scale explains the pressure.** Non-performing debt across the system exceeded VND 227,000 billion, about USD 9 billion, in March 2025; consumer-finance companies averaged NPL above 10% in the first half of 2025.
- **Contact hours are where regulators fine.** India restricts recovery calls to 8am–7pm, with penalties of ₹1 crore in September 2024, ₹3.80 lakh on 10 February 2026 and ₹11.5 lakh on 27 February 2026. Indonesia allows 08:00–20:00, Monday to Saturday; the Philippines treats contact before 6am or after 10pm as unreasonable.
- **Vietnam's enforcement levers have teeth.** Decree 21/2021 requires at least 10 days' notice before disposing of movable collateral; Law 96/2025, effective 15 October 2025, codified seizure without a court in Article 198a where the agreement exists and the security interest has third-party effect.

## The decision framework

Score it on what an auditor would ask, not what a demo shows.

| # | Criterion | Weight | What "high" looks like |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lawful basis and consent per contact | 20% | Every contact traces to a basis, a product and a date; withdrawal suppresses within one cycle |
| 2 | Data quality and contactability | 20% | Right-party rates measured per portfolio and channel, wrong numbers retired, no duplicate identities |
| 3 | Contact strategy governance | 15% | Hours, frequency and channel limits enforced by the system, not by agent memory |
| 4 | Audit trail and evidence | 15% | Recording, disposition and quality check retrievable per account for the retention period |
| 5 | Treatment measurement | 15% | Champion-challenger tests with same-age, same-bucket comparison; uplift attributed, not assumed |
| 6 | Third-party oversight | 10% | Agency clauses with audit rights and penalties; outsourced conduct treated as own conduct |
| 7 | Integration with servicing facts | 5% | Restructure, settlement and collateral status visible before a contact decision is made |

Criterion 5 is where programmes fail quietly: recovery rises when you call more; without controlled comparison the lift is volume, not intelligence.

## Options and trade-offs

| Option | Strength | Risks | Three-year cost shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| **Clean the data and govern contact** inside the current call centre | Fastest compliance win; no new platform; fixes what an auditor asks for | Depends on core systems exposing account and collateral facts | Mostly people and data remediation; lowest build |
| **Add voice bots and AI quality checks** on existing data | Cuts cost per contact; reviews far more calls than sampling | Automates bad data; conduct risk scales with volume; vendor cases are not your baseline | Front-loaded licence and integration, then per-minute cost that grows with volume |
| **Rebuild on a unified collections data model** | One customer, one exposure, one contact history; treatment becomes measurable | Longest path; needs business ownership, not only IT | Highest build over two years, lowest marginal cost after; the only option that makes criterion 5 real |

The second is not a substitute for the first: a bot dialling a wrong number faster is a bigger problem.

## The numbers

The sources carry no person-day baseline, so I give none. What is documented is unit economics:

- **Cost per contact:** vendor cases report cost per dollar recovered falling from 22¢ to 8¢ and cost per call down 75%. In one market an agent costs about ₹30,000 a month for 250 cases, with AI cited at 40–60% cheaper and 20 times the volume.
- **Cost of poor treatment strategy:** a card centre using champion-challenger reported a 30% cut in collections operating cost; a European bank reported 25% fewer collector minutes with the same money collected.
- **Cost of scale:** in Vietnam one lender moved from 200,000 to 5 million calls a month at halved operating cost; another ran 1,054,670 calls in eleven months, peaking at 52,152 a day.
- **Cost drivers:** data remediation and identity matching, consent reconstruction, contact-policy engine, recording and quality-check storage, integration to servicing, and the audit pack. No prices in the sources.

## What I would do in 30 / 60 / 90 days

### Next 30 days — measure the data, not the ambition

- Baseline contactability: right-party rate, wrong-number rate, duplicates, accounts with no valid contact.
- Inventory lawful basis and consent per product; find contacts traced to neither.
- Audit last quarter's contacts against hours, frequency and channel limits; publish the exceptions internally.

### Days 30 to 60 — make the rules executable

- Put hours, frequency and channel limits into the system as controls with an exception log, not a policy PDF.
- Run one controlled champion-challenger test inside a single bucket, same vintage, with a fixed contact ceiling.
- Price every change request at intake, including the ones arriving as "just a new SMS template".

### Days 60 to 90 — produce evidence, then scale

- Assemble the audit pack: recording coverage, quality-check sampling, disposition codes, retention, and agency clauses with audit rights.
- Decide the next increment on the first test's evidence, not a vendor deck.
- Retire what you cannot justify: contacts without a basis, numbers without an owner, history beyond five years.

## What I would not do

- **Not buy a voice bot before contact data is trustworthy.** That scales the error at a lower cost per error.
- **Not treat outsourced collection as transferred responsibility.** The expectation travels with the agent.
- **Not use a vendor's recovery uplift as the business case.** Without same-age comparison it measures contact volume.
- **Not widen contact hours or frequency to hit a monthly target.** It converts a data programme into an enforcement case.

## For the non-technical sponsor

Collections spends money on contacts and reputation on how they are made. The programme is about knowing who to contact, when you may contact them, and proving it afterwards. Fund data and controls first, automation second: the bot is cheaper once the numbers are right, and expensive once they are not. Before any demo, ask for contactability, consent coverage and audit evidence.

## Sources

- Vietnam debt-collection code of conduct, 31 March 2026, https://lsvn.vn/ban-hanh-bo-quy-tac-ung-xu-trong-hoat-dong-thu-hoi-no-trong-he-thong-ngan-hang-a172157.html
- Circular 11/2021/TT-NHNN, provisioning at 0/5/20/50/100% plus 0.75%, https://english.luatvietnam.vn/circular-no-11-2021-tt-nhnn-dated-july-30-2021-of-the-state-bank-of-vietnam-providing-the-classification-of-assets-risk-provisioning-levels-and-met-206806-doc1.html
- Credit-bureau history capped at five years, https://chinhsachonline.chinhphu.vn/lich-su-no-xau-duoc-cung-cap-trong-toi-da-5-nam-75461.htm
- Law 96/2025/QH15, Article 198a, seizure without a court, https://pbgdpl.camau.gov.vn/bai-viet/Ch%c3%adnh%20s%c3%a1ch%20m%e1%bb%9bi%20c%c3%b3%20hi%e1%bb%87u%20l%e1%bb%b1c%20t%e1%bb%ab%20th%c3%a1ng%206/quy-dinh-ve-quyen-thu-giu-tai-san-bao-dam.7142
- Decree 21/2021/ND-CP, notice periods for collateral, https://accgroup.vn/nghi-dinh-so-212021-nd-cp
- Reserve Bank of India, recovery-agent directions, https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/NotificationUser.aspx?Id=12378&Mode=0
- Penalty for out-of-hours contact, September 2024, https://www.business-standard.com/amp/finance/personal-finance/rs-1-cr-penalty-on-hdfc-bank-how-to-protect-yourself-from-recovery-agents-124091700205_1.html
- OJK on permitted collection hours, https://finansial.bisnis.com/read/20260507/89/1971988/ojk-tegaskan-aturan-penagihan-tidak-boleh-kasar-dan-harus-di-waktu-tertentu
- Champion-challenger in early collections, https://www.fico.com/en/newsroom/shanghai-pudong-development-bank-credit-card-centre-automates-early-collections

*Personal views. Client and employer details are anonymised. Figures are third-party estimates, not vendor quotes, and are dated November 2026.*
